Why Culture Trumps Pay in Home Care Recruiting & Retention – David Knack

Creating a Culture That Keeps Caregivers

As the owner of a marketing agency that specializes in home care, I’ve had countless conversations with agency owners about their biggest challenge, caregiver retention. And I’ll say this loud and clear: the secret isn’t just in how much you pay. It’s in how your caregivers feel.

I recently had the pleasure of interviewing David Knack from Zingage on our podcast. His insights on caregiver engagement and culture-building were incredibly timely and hit home for so many of the home care agencies we support.

Why Home Care Is a Culture-Driven Industry

David put it simply: “There’s no water cooler in home care.” Caregivers work in isolation, often only hearing from the office when something has gone wrong or when the agency needs a favor. That isolation is toxic. It leads to turnover, missed clock-ins, and staff burnout.

Here’s what makes the difference:

• Consistent recognition for dependable caregivers

• Segmented communication based on performance and tenure

• Automation that supports—not replaces—human connection

David’s company, Zingage, has built a platform that automates engagement, allowing agencies to reach the right caregiver with the right message at the right time. But even if you’re just starting, you can begin building a culture today, with or without software.

If you’re unsure where your agency stands, we offer a free Home Care Website Scan to help identify foundational gaps in visibility and user experience.

Watch how we grew an agency’s care hours by 400% (and how you can too)!

Why Culture Wins Over Compensation

Let’s face it: home care agencies can’t compete with $22/hour at Chick-fil-A or tuition reimbursement at Taco Bell. But what we can offer is meaning, recognition, and belonging.

David highlighted this perfectly:

“We’re creating meaningful work that makes a difference. The problem is making caregivers feel like they’re part of something bigger when they’re alone in the field.”

You don’t have to wait until you hit 100 caregivers to focus on culture. In fact, that’s exactly when it matters most.

What caregivers want more than anything:

• To feel seen and valued

• To have a relationship with the agency

   

• To be recognized for consistency, not just heroics

   

Need help building visibility around your agency’s values? Our Home Care SEO Services were built exactly for that.

My Wife’s Story (And Why This Hits Home)

Before we were married, my wife worked as a CNA. She cared deeply for her clients, often forming deep emotional bonds with them. I remember nights when she’d call me crying because the office treated her like a cog in the machine.

Those experiences stuck with me. They’re part of why I do what I do at Grow Senior Care Marketing. And they’re why I believe culture beats compensation—every time.

You Can’t Spreadsheet Your Way to a Strong Team

Let’s talk about spreadsheets. Yes, they’re a decent version one. But the minute you add more team members or try to scale processes, they become a liability.

David shared how Zingage’s clients go from:

• Manual gift card distribution → to automated recognition

   

• No-shows and clock-in chaos → to 98% self-managed caregiver attendance

   

• High staff turnover → to build habits that retain consistent team members

   

Want a step-by-step way to improve your caregiver management SOPs? Grab our Free Home Care SEO Checklist to see what’s missing from your online process.

Download our ultimate home care SEO and website checklist

Scaling Relationships with Segmentation & SOPs

You don’t need 1:1 relationships with every caregiver, but you do need systems that make each person feel personally seen.

David explained how Zingage groups caregivers based on:

• Tenure (e.g., 0–90 days, 6–12 months, etc.)

   

• Performance (e.g., consistent vs. inconsistent clock-ins)

   

• Behavior triggers (e.g., missed shifts, call-outs, lateness)

   

If you’re still building these systems manually, take a look at our Home Care Marketing Services for automation options that support growth.

Why “Reward Fatigue” is Real—and How to Avoid It

One key takeaway from David was that rewards alone won’t move the needle long-term.

“If all we have is a rewards platform, we just end up creating a pay raise in disguise.”

Over time, rewards become expected rather than appreciated. The key is to layer rewards into a broader employee experience that includes:

• Milestone celebrations (e.g., 10 perfect shifts)

   

• Recognition messages from leadership

   

• Video encouragements

   

• Survey feedback loops

   

• Peer shout-outs

   

Your office staff benefit too—less after-hours chaos, fewer clock-in issues, more time for meaningful engagement.

Real Agency Wins: What Culture-First Results Look Like

David shared stories of agencies that transformed:

• One agency thought their call-out alarm system was broken, it wasn’t. Zingage had dramatically improved its attendance rates.

   

• Another saw a huge reduction in after-hours calls just by linking points and rewards to behavior like timely clock-ins.

   

The ripple effect of fewer no-shows, better morale, and calmer admin teams can’t be overstated.

If you want to hear the full conversation, listen to the episode on the Grow Senior Care Marketing Podcast.

Start Small, Build Fast

If you’re feeling stuck in spreadsheets or just overwhelmed by retention struggles, here’s where to begin:

• Recognize the quiet consistency, not just the last-minute heroes

   

• Segment caregivers by tenure and behavior

• Build small SOPs that grow over time

• Invest in your staff, not just your caregivers

When you’re ready to scale, the Grow Senior Care Marketing team is here to help guide that growth.

Caregiver Culture & Retention: Your Questions Answered

Q: How can I improve caregiver retention without raising pay?
A: Focus on engagement. Build SOPs that recognize consistency, segment your communication, and reward behaviors that align with your values. Consider systems like Zingage that automate that process.

Q: What’s one simple thing I can do this week?
A: Start tracking clock-in streaks. Recognize caregivers who show up on time consistently and reward them every 5–10 shifts with a small gift or bonus.

Q: Is caregiver segmentation really necessary for small agencies?
A: Yes! Even with 20 caregivers, you can benefit from grouping them by tenure or behavior and tailoring your check-ins and messages accordingly.

Ready to Create a Culture That Retains Caregivers?

You don’t need a massive budget or complex tools to start making a difference in your caregiver culture. What you do need is clarity, consistency, and a willingness to try new things.

Whether you’re running on spreadsheets or scaling with tech, building a culture that values caregivers as people—not just workers—is the foundation for sustainable growth.

If you’re ready to take the next step, here are some free tools and recommended resources to help you get started:

👇 Explore These Helpful Resources

• 🎧 Listen to the full episode: Grow Senior Care Marketing Podcast

• 📋 Free SEO Checklist: Home Care SEO Checklist

• 🔎 Get a free audit: Home Care Website Scan

• 📈 See how we can help: Our Home Care Marketing Services

• 📚 Learn more about SEO: Home Care SEO Overview

• 🏠 Visit our homepage: Grow Senior Care Marketing

🤝 Connect with Zingage

If you’re ready to scale your caregiver engagement and reduce admin overload, Zingage is the partner to talk to.

• 🌐 Visit Zingage

• 👤 Connect with David Knack on LinkedIn

🎙️ Watch or Listen to the Podcast

Want to dive deeper into this conversation?

• ▶️ Watch the full interview on YouTube: Grow Senior Care Marketing on YouTube

• 🎧 Listen on our website: Grow Senior Care Marketing Podcast

If you’d like help building a system that empowers your team and retains your caregivers, let’s connect.

You can reach out here or connect with me on LinkedIn. I’d love to help your agency grow with the right people, the right message, and the right culture.

Thanks for reading,
Jeremy

Hope you found this to be helpful, if you’re ready to take your agency to the next level schedule your free home care marketing session with us now:

Schedule Your Free Ultimate Home Care Marketing Session, And We Will:

A $500 Value – Yours For Free